School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-These hi-lo books focus on high-stakes stories from European and U.S. history. Each begins with a brief overview, followed by profiles of a specific person or disaster. In Pirates and Shipwrecks, readers are introduced to a number of pirates and three shipwrecked crews. Two shipwrecks, the Bounty mutiny, the ill-fated Donner party, and a trek across Death Valley comprise Survival. Intriguing details about Ernest Shackleton's starving crew keep readers engaged. A map of the area where each event took place, a time line, and an abbreviated list of other historical events from the time period allow students an additional way to connect with the material. Aside from an author's note that attributes the story of Daniel Collins to a published narrative, none of the other tales have references. The author uses the phrases savage islanders and natives who would kill them to describe encounters survivors had with people from island nations. VERDICT Because of the stereotypical language and lack of sources, this title is not recommended. Librarians should instead seek out Lauren Tarshis's Nature Attacks!-Hilary Writt, Sullivan University, Lexington, KY © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Booklist Review
Warning: these feats aren't for the faint of heart. From icy depths and scorching valleys to the rumored consumption of human flesh, this entry in the Mystery & Mayhem series examines notorious survival stories. In five succinct chapters, each bookended by annotated expedition maps and a brief bill of historical context, McCarthy covers Ernest Shackleton's voyage from Plymouth, England, to Antarctica; William Bligh's trek to Timor; William Lewis Manly's slog through Death Valley; Charlotte Picard's course to Senegal; and the Donner Party's infamous tussle with an early winter. Although speculative musings (Imagine how the remaining crew . . . felt) at times offset hard facts and direct quotations, the conversational tone, hair-raising anecdotes, and fairly comprehensive glossary make this a handy primer for any budding thrill seeker.--Shemroske, Briana Copyright 2016 Booklist