School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 2-Another entry in the series of picture book and beginning reader mash-ups. Beret-wearing Tate is a boy who likes to draw and Pup would like to be drawn, but he's never the subject of Tate's work. "Can you find ten bugs?" or birds or cats or clowns in Tate's pictures? Yes to them all, but no rainbow-hue poodles appear. So Pup takes drastic action and runs away with the circus-he is having a blast on the trapeze, as a lion tamer, and riding the elephant. But Tate is sadly missing Pup, whom he draws repeatedly. Now, you can find 10 pictures of Pup. Kirsch's easy-to-read text is perfectly complemented by his French-inspired illustrations. His use of details, whimsy, color, and great facial expressions really bring this simple tale to life. The amazing clowns are worth the price of admission. VERDICT This is a great beginning reader with fun illustrations. A strong purchase.-Catherine Callegari, Gay-Kimball Library, Troy, NH © Copyright 2018. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Horn Book Review
As Tate draws pictures, he ignores his dog playing nearby. On alternating spreads, readers can spot lots of objects ("But there is no Pup") within the pictures Tate has drawn. Tate learns his lesson after Pup runs away ("Now Tate will always draw Pup"). With its very simple text, detailed illustrations, and interactive picture-puzzle elements, this easy reader will keep new readers' interests. (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
In this amusing early reader, a young left-handed artist ignores his talented poodle until Pup runs away to join the circus. The little boy, Tate, wears a black beret and a jaunty, red scarf as he creates pencil sketches of his cats, flowers and insects in his garden, and clowns at the circus. Pup makes desperate bids for Tate's attention, painting his own fur with tubes of paint, swinging from a tree branch, and juggling balls for the clowns. When Pup follows the clowns and joins the circus, Tate is sad at the loss of his pet. He posts 10 colored-pencil portraits of Pup outside the circus tent, leading to a happy reunion of boy and dog. The story's clever construction has a brightly colored illustration of Tate busily sketching on one double-page spread followed by a spread displaying Tate's large, black-and-white drawing that includes 10 similar items in a busy seek-and-find design. The minimal text works well as an early reader, but this clever story will also be a fine choice for preschoolers who are learning to count to 10, and it even teaches a little about different art methods. Lively illustrations in watercolor and ink are filled with tiny details and funny expressions for Tate and Pup and their feline friends. All the human characters, including the clowns, present white.The combination of a simple but satisfying plot and vibrant art adds up to a story that succeeds on several levels. Yes, we can find Pup! And we'd like to see him (and Tate) again. (Early reader/picture book. 2-8) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
