Horn Book Review
The titular protagonist from Piper Perish is finally in NYC to work as an assistant to a big name in the art business before attending her dream art school. Now, to earn tuition money, she must deal with creating art for someone else instead of for herself. There's less emotional urgency in this sequel's similar journal-style narration, but Piper remains spunky and admirably ready to make it on her own. (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
A young artist moves to the big city.In the follow-up to Piper Perish (2017), Cagan's plucky first-person narrator has escaped the confines of her distressing home life in Houston to follow her dreams of attending art school and supporting herself as an artist. Moving to New York City with the money she saved waiting tables, talented 18-year-old Piper now finds herself in the rare position of being hired by a celebrated artist to serve as his assistant as she awaits news on the financial aid package she desperately needs to attend art school. Piper is ready to remake herself and start a new life, even as she gets a reality check from native New Yorker Silas, a would-be beau and seeming "real live Edward Gorey character," who warns her that New York is "a city with no respect for the past. Nostalgia just gets swept up with the trash here." Trash eventually becomes an important artistic element for Piper as she tries to establish her own autonomy and negotiate budding romantic and artistic relationships in the shadow of the domineering artist who's hired her to execute his vision. This enjoyable read contains many New York City details that ring true and offers a glimpse into the contemporary world of young struggling artists. Piper and Silas are white.A fast-paced bildungsroman offering an engaging portrait of the artist as a young woman. (Fiction. 14-18) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Picking up where Piper Perish (2017) left off, this book finds the young artist Piper in New York City. She has successfully escaped humdrum Texas, but that doesn't mean her challenges are over. The city is overwhelming, phantasmagorical in how different it is from Piper's Houston home. To master the working-artist lifestyle, Piper has to balance the vibrant chaos of New York's social scene with ground-level realities (the expense of living, navigating egos without crushing your own). Ultimately, Piper learns that attaining one's dream isn't the biggest challenge it's keeping that dream alive once you attain it. Cagan once again uses the vehicle of a diary to unfold Piper's life, employong a stream-of-consciousness technique to show readers the highs and lows of Piper's day-to-day life. The book is also a love letter to New York, told through the lens of new experiences and revelations. This is an automatic pick-up for fans of the previous book and a great read for any artist aspiring to greatness.--Reinhardt Suarez Copyright 2018 Booklist
