Publisher's Weekly Review
Three witches' cupboard is bare save for "a small, dry bone." Why not make bone soup? Before readers can say Stone Soup, the weird sisters embark on a quest to secure ingredients from their nasty neighbors. The first candidates, a fuzzy monster and a ghost, are skeptical and grumpy ("Bone soup? Impossible! Go away! There will be time for your tricks later," they both say). But they can't resist adding to the pot, and soon the entire creepy community has made bone-chilling contributions (a werewolf adds "Wrinkled fingers, o-o-o-old toenails"). When the hungry crowd turns demanding, the initial monster's little daughter steps up to ensure that soup's on. The story suffers somewhat from narrative sprawl (the text has more refrains than it needs), but Capucilli (the Biscuit series) deserves kudos for employing plenty of tasty vocabulary. Drawings by Knight (Good Knight, Bad Knight), meanwhile, feel as ghoulishly bright as a jack-o'-lantern. A Halloween soup recipe-parsnips and carrots take the place of fingers-concludes the book. Ages 4-8. (July) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Horn Book Review
In this playful Halloween-themed retelling of the folktale "Stone Soup," three hungry witches have only a bone to eat. They beg local monsters for eerie ingredients such as earthworms, eyeballs, and cobwebs, promising there's no trick, just a tasty treat. Greens, blues, and oranges dominate the cartoonish, digitally colored charcoal and pencil illustrations. A soup recipe (substituting edible ingredients for witchy ones) is appended. (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
"Stone Soup" gets a Halloween remake.Three hungry witches, finding only a dry bone in the cupboard, take their cauldron door to door collecting ingredients for their bone soup. Both the neighbors, who are initially suspicious of the witches, and their additions to the pot will be unfamiliar to children used to grandma's chicken soup: A ghost contributes a giant's eye; a ghoul brings a lizard's tail; a werewolf adds old toenails. The beguiling smell attracts more and more creatures, and as their hunger increases, their patience grows thin: They will not put up with any tricks from the witches. (Capucilli's wordplay here is a delight: " Let's wrap this up now,' mumbled the mummy. / Don't rattle me further,' clattered the skeleton.") Just as it looks as if the witches will be part of the soup, a monster child saves the day, and bone soup is shared and enjoyed by all. Knight's illustrations, made with charcoal and pencils and colored digitally, have just the right mix of creepy and humorous, treading the line between scary and fun. His palette is suitably Halloween-y. Just right for sharing with neighbors this Octobereither the tale or the (real) recipe that follows, or maybe both. (author's note) (Picture book/folktale. 4-8) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
