School Library Journal Review
YA-- Hope, memory, love lost, and love regained are the major themes that thread their way through this easily read collection of short stories. Ranging in topic from a tale of a young woman who finds from a stranger the courage she never thought she had, to a portrait of a bride-to-be who is forced to choose between two loves, the sensitively written offerings portray a kaleidoscope of human emotions that will touch the hearts of YA readers and may even provide some bibliotherapy to those for which a familiar situation, event, or emotion is evoked. --Roberta Lisker, W. T. Woodson High School, Fairfax, VA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
Pilcher's collection of heartwarming but formulaic stories set in cozy England spent nine weeks on PW 's hardcover bestseller list. (July) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Kirkus Review
A second story collection by the British author of such runaway hits as The Shell Seekers and September, full of what can only be called quintessential women's magazine fiction, featuring tales for every major holiday, heroines straight out of the Laura Ashley catalogue, lots of National Trust properties in the background, comfortingly predictable endings, plenty of romance and even more sentimentality. Most conspicuous here are the shafted British thirtysomething female stories, like ``The Blackberry Day.'' In it, Claudia returns to the village in Scotland where she grew up only to read in the paper that the London businessman she's been dating has up and married someone else; fortunately, she reads this tidbit in the company of her old friend Magnus, whom she's just beginning to see with new eyes. Then there are Pilcher's studies of very recognizable dilemmas: the compromises required in marriage, as in ``Playing a Round with Love,'' with its much too easy, darling- we're-having-a-baby ending; connubial love in the golden years, rekindled in the ``The Watershed'' on the occasion of a 30th wedding-anniversary party; children hanging tough in the wake of a parent's death, as 12-year-old William does in ``The Dolls House''; and still more romance, typically between simple but ruggedly handsome farm managers and the princess-like daughters at the big house. Pilcher fans will doubtless go all atremble--even though her novels are much more satisfying than these unresolved stories. Others will find them platitudinous, obvious, and, in terms of scope and variety, a little like another article on 15 great ways to cook chicken.
Booklist Review
In the story entitled "Last Morning," Laura and her soon-to-be-married son Tom take an early morning walk along the seashore. After she has told him what a fine choice he has made in Virginia, his fiance, Tom tells his mother, "basically, she's like you . . . beneath the capability and the brightness . . . she's gentle and wise." Certainly the same might be said regarding the author herself. Throughout this collection of stories, Pilcher maintains a pervasive gentility along with an abiding wisdom. Filled with poignant scenes, romantic and bittersweet, these stories, many written earlier in the author's career, will appeal to readers of Pilcher's very successful novels, The Shell Seekers and September. ~--Alice Joyce