Library Journal Review
The second volume of DC's revamped Superman begins with the portrayal of the enduring image of a superhero who is sure of himself and his role as a beacon of hope and protector of the human race. The villains Superman encounters here are tormented by similar issues he has already overcome-no home, no real family, and no friends to offer support. Yet Superman prevails over each of his foes, transcending the challenges owing to his certainty of his chosen path. But when Helspont, a descendant of the ancient alien race of Daemonites, ultimately reveals his role in the shaping of humankind, Superman's confidence is shattered, leaving the hero unable to ascertain what direction he must take next. Though the collection's overarching concept deserves merit, the actual executions fall below par, with the final issue by Scott Lobdell and Fabian Nicieza picking up much of the slack from the issues penned and penciled by Jurgens. At moments when the overall feel of the book seems dated, its flaws are marked by the verbose, thought-bubble exposition and drawing style that screams the Nineties. New readers, especially those who are more familiar with the films, should look instead to J. Michael Straczynski's Superman: Earth One, which provides a much more realistic and grounded reimagining of the hero. Verdict Longtime Superman and Wildstorm fans will most appreciate this volume, especially the integration of Wildstorm into the current DC universe. For the general graphic novels reader, this collection fails in presenting an accessible, contemporary Superman.-Laura Gallardo, St. Louis (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.